Archive for May, 2010

Colombia Election Results: No Surprise but Big Surprise

0

Colombians voted today and as expected, no presidential candidate achieved fifty percent plus one, thereby triggering a second round of voting June 20. What was totally unexpected was the way in which the vote was split: the U candidate, Juan Manuel Santos, took the lion’s share with over 46 percent, while the Green party’s Antanas Mockus was a distant second with less than 22 percent, contradicting recent opinion polls that had shown in a dead heat with the Santos. Santos won the vote broadly, leading in every province (departamento) except Putumayo, where Mockus came out on top.

Another surprise is that the  Cambio Radical’s Germán Vargas finished third, with  just over ten percent, and the Polo Democratico’s Gustavo Petro ended in fourth place with about nine percent. Conservative Noemi Sanin placed fifth with 6 percent, despite having placed consistently third in pre-election polls. The liberal party’s Rafael Pardo garnered less than five percent of the national vote, thereby depriving him of state’s campaign cost subsidy which the top five candidates will enjoy.

Only the top finishers, Santos and Mockus, will be on the ballot in the second round, while the others can now only act as kingmakers, pledging their voter base to one of the two, although in the end, voters might not follow their candidate’s choice. A Santos second round win is almost guaranteed, needing only an additional four percent, while Mockus would have to add almost 29 percent, an almost impossible feat. Any offer Mockus will make to the other parties will sound hollow, while any candidate who walks across the line to the Santos camp is guaranteed real power sharing. Mockus didn’t help his cause by loudly rejecting Gustavo Petro’s offer of a second round alliance prior to the election, despite the fact that the Polo party was the surest bet to align with him. The second round looks to be a simple formality, only serving to reaffirm Santos’ resounding win.

What caused the Mockus support to collapse? Perhaps it was the sum of his many imprudent statements made to the press, including his promise to raise taxes to pay for social programs, made just last week and after the last opinion poll. Perhaps cool heads prevailed today, many Colombians thinking twice about putting an eccentric idealist at the helm of a country still immersed in a bloody battle with terrorists and drug traffickers, preferring to continue with the party that has allowed them to enjoy an unprecedented level of security, letting them continue with their Democratic Security program. It’s not a coincidence that all candidates promised to continue Democratic Security, but in the final analysis, who can best run the program except those who started it, Santos having been an important player in his role as defense minister under outgoing president Alvaro Uribe?

Perhaps the most telling evidence on the effectiveness of the U party’s relentless war on illegal armed groups is that today’s election unfurled without incident, Colombians turning-out to vote in record numbers. No explosions, kidnappings or shootings as in past elections, although the police did detect and disarm a few bombs. The electoral registrar’s system performed flawlessly this time, ballot counts rolling in quickly, with almost all reporting within two hours after polls closed at four pm local time, unlike the recent congressional and senatorial elections which took days to tally and were marred by controversy.

* Election results from the Registradura Nacional de Colombia

Will Colombia Fall for the Mockus Pocus?

2

The Colombian presidential elections are just around the corner and voters seem destined to split the vote between the Green party’s Antanas Mockus and outgoing president Alvaro Uribe’s pick, Juan Manuel Santos. As Colombia’s electoral process requires fifty percent plus one to win, it’s almost guaranteed that there will be a second round of voting June 20th with just the two leading candidates on the ballot.

Photo by Kristen Price

Santos, during his three year stint as Uribe’s defense minister, saw his popularity skyrocket for his involvement in such brilliant military operations as “Jaque” (Checkmate), which resulted in the liberation of the most important hostages held by the FARC rebel group. However, Santos lacks the charisma and oratory skills of his mentor, and this is probably what has contributed to keeping him well below 40 percent in this election’s opinion polls, while Mockus’ numbers have been on the rise. What propelled Mockus to a statistical tie was the ominous threat recently uttered by Venezuela’s dictator, Hugo Chavez: if Santos won, he said, war  between the neighboring countries would ensue. Chavez is as feared  as he is reviled in Colombia, and has a long history of meddling in the neighboring nation’s affairs.

Mockus was a two term mayor of the Colombian capital, Bogota, who was widely heralded for his innovative social policies. He is also known for his eccentricities, which included dressing up as a super hero,  demonstrating in front of the cameras how to shower with a minimum of water, wearing nothing more than a skimpy Speedo, and even mooning an university auditorium audience. His recent wedding was held in a zoo,  he and his bride riding on the back of an elephant. Despite his antics, the former philosophy and mathematics professor finds his core supporters among the young,  the largest demographic group  in Colombia, the country’s population has an average age of 27.6 years, as compared to 36.8 in the USA, or 40.7 in Canada*. Strangely, his popularity is marginal among the country’s poor, the very social stratum most of his political platform is aimed at. The reason for this phenomenon could be that the nation’s disenfranchised are weary of the violence that still stalks their lives, and Mockus has done little to quiet rumors that he would be soft on the rebel groups,  narcotics traffickers, and gangs that haunt both cities and rural areas.

Colombia is a complicated country with problems most democracies don’t have to contend with, such as a 48 percent poverty rate** and heavily armed rebel and criminal groups roaming through most of its territory, not to mention continuous threats from Venezuela and its allies. Under the Uribe administration, personal security has increased dramatically, government control having been returned to the major cities and principal highways, as well as vast swaths of rural land. This was achieved via a hard line policy, applying relentless military force, instead of negotiating with illegal organizations.  All previous attempts at resolving Colombia’s conflicts by political means have been disastrous. Mockus’ rival,  Santos, knows something about such fiascos, as he oversaw former president Andres Pastrana’s ill conceived peace plan that left FARC rebels in control of a territory the size of Switzerland from 1999-2002. This allowed the terrorists to deeply entrench themselves and gain strength, not to mention massacre unprotected local populations.  Uribe, who succeeded Pastrana, has managed to disband virtually all paramiltary groups and has severely damaged both the FARC and ELN rebels. All current candidates have pledged to continue Uribe’s “Democratic Security” policy. However, political observers have serious concerns over a possible Mockus triumph.

Mockus has raised alarms with his many shocking statements in front of the press, stirring up further controversy by later denying what he clearly said. One of his biggest gaffes was confessing he admired Hugo Chavez, later claiming he was misinterpreted.  In another interview Mockus said the unthinkable: that he if a foreign government (namely Ecuador or Venezuela) called for the extradition of Uribe or Santos, he would permit it should Colombian courts avail it. He also has expressed the wish to transform Colombia into a country without an army, similar to Costa Rica. In a country as embattled as Colombia, musing about disbanding the military may sound insane. In yet another blunder, he asserted that doctors should earn no more than one million pesos a month (about 500 dollars), thereby alienating medical professionals. Finally, he recently said what every politician in the world knows you should never say if you want to get elected: that he would raise taxes! You can show your derriere to the world, but talk of tax increases is like kryptonite! Mockus may have done irreparable damage to his campaign this time.

Colombia can’t risk a four year experiment with Mockus and his Green party at this time, as the security problems of this country are still the main focus and require the leadership of someone who is pragmatic rather than idealistic. An enormous mistake could be made during these elections, thanks to a young population that has a false sense of security and little idea of the fragility of the relatively peaceful times they’re living in, let alone that this only exists because of the hard battles that have been fought over the last several years.

* National average age statistics from the CIA World Factbook.
** 2008 estimate by DANE, the Colombian federal statistical bureau.

Venezuela “Expert” Appointed as the Next Ambassador to Colombia

1

In a move seen as a confirmation that Washington is awakening to the threat posed by the Chavez regime in Venezuela, US president Barack Obama recently nominated Peter Michael McKinley as ambassador to Colombia. McKinley, currently ambassador to Peru, was born in Venezuela, and is said to be an expert on matters regarding Colombia’s troublesome neighbor. His resume includes a book he wrote on the colonial history of Venezuela.

McKinley will replace outgoing ambassador William Brownfield, who is extremely well known and liked in Colombia. McKinley will assume office when Colombia’s new president will be known, which according to current opinion polls may well be the Green party’s Antanas Mockus, a center-left candidate. Mockus has publicly expressed admiration for Venezuela’s dictator, Hugo Chavez, later attempting to mitigate what he had said. Chavez has for several years taken a hard line against Colombia, disrupting virtually all trade between the countries, and recently meddled in the electoral process, claiming that there would be war if Mockus’ main rival, Juan Manuel Santos, was elected. Polls began to favor Mockus immediately after Chavez’ statement.

McKinley will take his post at a time of turmoil, with increasing worries about what Chavez’ next move will be, and an uncertain future political direction in Colombia, the Unied States’ most important South American ally. Venezuela’s military build-up and alliances with Russia and Iran, as well as the spread of his leftist anti-American Bolivarian revolution in Latin America are high on Washington’s list of worries.

Patrick Duddy is the current US ambassador to Venezuela. He was expelled by the Chavez regime in September of 2008 on accusations of planning a coup against the Venezuelan leader. Diplomatic relations with Venezuela were not restored until eight months later, in July of 2009, under the Obama administration, when Duddy was returned to his former post after intense negotiations. In view of the precarious position of the mission in Caracas, having a Venezuela-literate representative in Bogota becomes critical.

Go to Top